Renewed Calls For Backdoor Access To Encryption Have All The Same Flaws

From All Hands

For security experts, the US government's debate over accessing end-to-end encryption sounds like a broken record -- with the same logical flaws they've pointed out for years. The latest push came Friday at the Justice Department's "Lawful Access Summit" in Washington, DC. The arguments from both sides sound eerily familiar, even if they were spouted by different individuals and companies. Where former US Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein called it "responsible encryption" in 2017, current Attorney General William Barr called it "lawful access" in a letter sent to Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg on Friday. FBI Director Christopher Wray echoed former director James Comey's remarks from 2014, arguing that the agency wasn't seeking a backdoor, but rather a "front door" to access encrypted messages. While the call to give governments access to encrypted messages in 2016 was highlighted by a battle between Apple and the FBI, the fight in 2019 lies between the Justice Department and Facebook. The renewed debate between our privacy and the government's need to access private systems for the sake of public safety comes months after Facebook said it intends to encrypt all of its messaging services.

Facebook is the top provider of reports to law enforcement on child exploitation cases, but the Justice Department worries that if the company encrypts all its messaging services, investigators would be left in the dark. Wray said at the summit. Facebook's move forces it into a tricky balancing act. The company opted to adopt end-to-end encryption in an effort to shore up questions about its ability to responsibly handle our data. But that very move now puts it in the crosshairs of the US government. End-to-end encryption is a security measure where content in messages is kept hidden even from the companies that provide that service. Police can serve a search warrant to the likes of Facebook and Apple for messages, but the companies wouldn't be able to provide them because of that encryption. Political activists and dissidents also rely on end-to-end encryption in fear that more oppressive governments are spying on their messages.

Security experts warn that by giving US law enforcement access to encrypted messages, other nations will follow with similar demands. Jake Williams, founder of cybersecurity firm Rendition Infosec. A coalition of more than 60 international civil rights groups signed a letter to Zuckerberg on Friday, countering the points that the Justice Department laid out. The letter highlighted that end-to-end encryption protects millions of people from oppressive regimes and potential hackers. It also called for Zuckerberg to continue Facebook's plans to encrypt its messaging services. The Justice Department argued that there could be a middle ground with security and privacy for all, as well as a way for governments to view people's messages. At the summit, Barr called on tech companies to develop a way to provide "secure legal access," something experts for years have said is impossible. The attorney general didn't offer any potential suggestions following his remarks. The concern is that by providing governments access to encrypted messages, it leaves an opening for potential hackers to steal that same key. It's why Apple CEO Tim Cook refused to build a backdoor for the FBI investigating a terrorist's iPhone, noting that it could potentially be stolen by hackers and open up access to millions of other people's iPhones in the future. At the summit, Deputy Attorney General Jeffrey Rosen specifically called out Apple over its encrypted messages. Sen. Ron Wyden, a Democrat from Oregon who has proposed legislation banning government backdoors, blasted the Justice Department's arguments Friday. He pointed out that US tech companies are more cooperative with law enforcement. Also, criminals would just move onto other platforms if "lawful access" was enabled, he said. Wyden said in a statement.

As the President, you will inspire others to create other phenomenal imaginations of their own. The world needs many people who are proud of their own "Imagination". Each of us has the ability to imagine such powerful dreams for our future, which can change the destiny of millions of people. Let’s think about a few people who had unreal imaginations -- Henry Ford imagined an 8-cylinder car and then achieved it. The Wright Brothers imagined men could ? John F. Kennedy said that we would have a man on the moon and then achieved it. Ask yourself right now, "Where did they all dream of those achievements ? They did their dreaming in their own nation called Imagination! You need to take some personal time and evaluate how you are handling your nation. Are you proud of what you are imagining you can be or what you can do? If you answer that question truthfully, you will either be enthused or disillusioned.

You truly need to re-examine your nation. I suggest that you brainstorm, which means to take some time for yourself and just write down all the dreams that you have but never even wrote down. I also recommend that you write down 100 of them and then put them away for 2 days so that they can sink in a little. When you go back and read them, your inner spirit will direct you to the one that you need to focus on and begin to design with your own "Imagination". Each of us is empowered to create wealth for ourselves in every aspect of life -- spiritually, physically, and ? I challenge you right now to utilize your God-given imagination and imagine whatever you want to be then you will empowered to run your nation in the most productive methods possible. This alone will entirely change your life for the better, because now you have a responsibility as a President of a nation - your "Imagination". Find Your Why NOW! Author's Bio: John is an International Motivational Speaker who shocks millions globally by exposing the truth about how to achieve monumental life success despite the labels that society has placed on you. Through his award winning live seminars, power-packed training programs, live tele-classes and websites John Di Lemme has made success a reality for thousands of people worldwide. Please Register or Login to post new comment. LOOKING PROFESSIONAL SENSITIVITY TRAINING FOR MANAGERS?